Reason, Evidence and Example: Building a Stronger Primary 5 English Argument

A reason is not evidence. An example is not automatically evidence. And evidence is not useful merely because it is true.

That sounds fussy until we look at what happens when students blur them together. A child says, “Exercise is good because my cousin plays football.” The cousin is an example. But what does the example prove? Why does it support the claim? What exactly is the reason?

Strong arguments separate the jobs: reasons explain why a claim should be accepted, evidence supports those reasons, and examples make an idea concrete.

This article continues the argument pathway around the protected Top 100 Vocabulary List for Primary 5 (AL1 Grade) Advanced.

Three different jobs

Part	Job	Question
Reason	explains why the claim makes sense	Why?
Evidence	supports or tests the reason	What supports this?
Example	shows a specific case	Can you show me one?

Consider the claim: “Schools should reduce food waste.”

• Reason: Wasting edible food uses resources without producing a benefit.
• Evidence: Records showing large amounts of untouched food being discarded would support the claim.
• Example: A school might offer smaller default portions and allow students to take more if needed.

The example is useful because it illustrates a possible solution. It does not by itself prove the size of the problem.

Why examples feel stronger than they are

Stories are memorable. If one person has a dramatic experience, we naturally pay attention. But one case cannot always support a general claim.

“My brother studies late at night and scores well” does not prove that late-night study is best for all students. It tells us one person’s experience. A stronger argument would consider sleep, concentration, study quality and individual differences.

Vocabulary for distinguishing support

Function	Useful words
give reason	because, since, one reason, due to
add evidence	evidence, data, observation, record, finding
introduce example	for example, for instance, such as
explain significance	this matters because, this suggests, therefore
limit claim	however, may, can, in some cases
compare support	stronger, weaker, more relevant, more reliable

Relevant evidence beats impressive evidence

Suppose the question is whether a new reading programme helped Primary 5 students read more often. A statistic about how many books exist in the school library is impressive but not directly relevant. A record of borrowing frequency before and after the programme is much more useful.

Students should learn to ask: Does this evidence answer the exact question?

The support ladder

1. State the claim.
2. Give one reason.
3. Choose evidence that is relevant to that reason.
4. Add an example if it helps the reader picture the idea.
5. Explain why the support matters.
6. Check whether the evidence is strong enough for the conclusion.

Oral English: from anecdote to reasoning

Weak: I think volunteering is good because my aunt volunteers.

Stronger: Volunteering can benefit communities because it adds time and effort to work that needs support. For example, volunteers may help distribute food or assist at community events. My aunt’s experience is one personal example, but the wider reason is that volunteer effort can increase what an organisation is able to do.

The student has now separated personal illustration from general reasoning.

Comprehension: evidence can be inside the wording

When a passage asks how we know a character is anxious, the evidence may be behavioural: repeated checking, hesitation, trembling hands, short responses. The answer should select the most relevant details and explain them rather than copying everything nearby.

“She was anxious because she checked the message five times and kept looking towards the door. These repeated actions show that she was uncertain and waiting for something important.”

Composition: examples make abstract ideas visible

Abstract words such as responsibility, compassion and resilience become convincing when the story supplies examples of behaviour.

• Responsibility: returning borrowed equipment without being reminded.
• Compassion: noticing distress and offering help.
• Resilience: recovering after failure and trying a revised approach.
• Integrity: admitting a mistake when hiding it would be easier.

In narrative writing, the example is often the scene itself.

Evidence quality: four checks

Check	Question
relevance	Does it support this exact reason?
reliability	Can the source or observation be trusted?
sufficiency	Is there enough support?
interpretation	Am I explaining it accurately?

One strong detail can sometimes be enough for a narrow claim. A broad claim usually needs broader support.

The dangerous word: proves

Students love proves because it sounds decisive. But most school examples merely support, suggest or indicate.

• This example shows one way the policy can help.
• The evidence supports the claim.
• The pattern suggests a relationship.
• The data indicate improvement.

Choosing the weaker verb can actually make the argument stronger because the language becomes more accurate.

Reasoning repair clinic

Weak support	Problem	Repair
It works because my friend likes it.	preference used as evidence	Explain the mechanism or wider benefit.
One student improved, so everyone will.	overgeneralisation	Present it as one example, not universal proof.
There are lots of numbers, so the evidence is strong.	quantity mistaken for relevance	Check what the numbers actually measure.
The writer says it, so it must be true.	claim confused with evidence	Inspect the support the writer provides.
This example is interesting.	interest does not equal usefulness	Explain how it supports the claim.

A seven-day support workout

Day	Task
1	Separate ten statements into claim, reason, evidence and example.
2	Give two different reasons for one opinion.
3	Find one relevant and one irrelevant piece of evidence for a claim.
4	Turn a personal anecdote into a properly limited example.
5	Practise support, suggest, indicate and prove.
6	Give a two-minute oral answer using one reason and one developed example.
7	Review a comprehension answer and underline claim, evidence and explanation.

For parents and tutors: ask “What job is this sentence doing?”

When a child speaks or writes an argument, identify the role of each sentence. Is it the claim? A reason? An example? Evidence? Explanation? If two sentences do the same job, perhaps another reasoning move is missing.

Primary 5 to Primary 6: support becomes faster when the parts are named

Once students can name these jobs, they can diagnose their own answers. “I have a claim and an example, but I have not explained the reason.” That is metacognition made practical.

---

Continue the Primary 5 Argument suite

Pair this article with From Opinion to Argument. Then return to the Primary 5 AL1 Vocabulary Hero and choose words that can anchor reasons, evidence and examples.

The goal is not to make every answer longer. It is to make every sentence earn its place.