A child entering secondary school through DSA may have spent years learning from a primary-school coach, private instructor or community organisation. The secondary school may use different terminology, techniques, routines or expectations. The child can feel confused when familiar methods are corrected or replaced.
This does not automatically mean the previous coach was wrong or the school is teaching badly. Different programmes may use different approaches for sound reasons. Parents should help the child understand the new expectations and avoid creating a conflict between instructors.
- Ask the school what core techniques and routines it expects students to follow.
- Help the child identify exactly what is different from previous training.
- Avoid telling the child to ignore either instructor.
- Where appropriate, ask whether the former coach and school instructor can clarify the learning sequence.
- Give the student time to practise the new method before judging results.
Why the change can feel bigger than it looks
A student may be familiar with a primary-school coach who understands their personality, strengths and habits. A secondary-school instructor may begin with a group routine and may not yet know the child well. Instructions may sound more direct, technical or demanding.
The student may also have to unlearn habits that worked in a previous setting but are not suitable for the new programme. That can feel like losing progress even when the change is part of development.
Separate a different method from a poor method
There can be several ways to teach a skill. Coaches may use different terminology, sequences or equipment. The important question is whether the method is appropriate, safe and consistent with the school’s programme, not whether it is identical to the previous instructor’s method.
Parents should not try to adjudicate specialist coaching differences without the necessary expertise. Ask the child to describe the instruction and, where appropriate, ask the school to explain why the method is being used.
Help the child explain the difference clearly
- What did your previous coach ask you to do?
- What is the school instructor asking you to do now?
- Which part feels unfamiliar or difficult?
- Did the instructor explain why the technique or routine is different?
- Can you demonstrate the new instruction slowly and safely?
The aim is to make the conflict specific. ‘The new coach is wrong’ does not help the student learn. ‘I was taught to position my hands this way, but the school is asking me to change them’ gives the adults something concrete to discuss.
Ask the school about its expected approach
The DSA commitment is to the allocated school and the selected talent area. The school is responsible for explaining its programme and the expectations for students. Ask which techniques are foundational, which are still being developed and how feedback should be applied.
- Which method should the child follow during school sessions?
- Are there previous habits the child needs to change?
- How long should the student expect to take to adjust?
- Can the child continue private lessons without conflicting with the school programme?
- Should the external instructor be informed of the school’s approach?
MOE’s DSA-Sec guidance explains the talent-area commitment in general. The exact coaching methods and development pathway are school-specific, so the allocated school’s current programme information should take priority.
If the child wants to continue the former coach
Parents do not need to stop an established relationship automatically. First ask whether the private instructor can support the school’s approach or focus on a different, complementary skill. If the instructors are teaching incompatible techniques, the child may become confused and need a temporary pause or adjustment.
A useful conversation with the former coach is respectful and specific: ‘The school is asking the student to work on this method. Can your sessions reinforce that approach, or should we focus on a different foundation?’ The coach may be able to adapt, or may explain why the approaches differ.
Give the new relationship time to develop
The student may need several sessions to understand the new instructor’s expectations. Encourage the child to observe, ask questions and practise the agreed steps. Avoid judging the entire programme after one difficult session.
However, persistent humiliation, unsafe instruction, discriminatory treatment or an inability to raise genuine safety concerns should not be dismissed as normal adjustment. In those circumstances, document what happened and contact the appropriate school staff.
Frequently asked questions
Does the secondary-school coach always have to be right?
The school is responsible for its programme, but parents can ask respectful questions when instructions are unclear or raise a safety concern. Do not turn a difference in method into an accusation without understanding it.
Should we keep the primary-school coach?
That depends on whether the external coaching supports the school’s methods and whether the child’s total workload remains sustainable.
What if the child says the old method feels easier?
A new method can feel awkward at first. Ask the school why the change is needed and give the student time to practise, while monitoring safety and wellbeing.
Can two instructors use different approaches?
Sometimes, but the student needs clarity about which approach applies in which context. Where methods conflict, ask the instructors to clarify the objectives.
A change of instructor is part of many students’ development. Parents can make the transition easier by listening carefully, asking for clear explanations and helping the child practise one coherent approach at a time.