eduKate Singapore

VIEW THIS AS

Auto mode follows the Route Engine until you choose a viewpoint.

YOU ARE HERE

ROUTE CHECK

CONNECTED TO

WHAT NEXT

Use the canonical route for this room, or HELP if you are unsure.

Next useful routeCanonical hubHELP

Singapore Property, HDB and Housing | HDB Jumbo Flats and Conversion Scheme: Joining Two Adjoining Flats, MOP and Resale

—

by

eduKate Asia

A jumbo HDB flat is not simply a large five-room apartment. Some jumbo flats were created when two smaller adjoining flats were combined, while HDB’s Conversion Scheme permits eligible families to seek approval to buy and join specified adjoining resale flats. HDB’s current public guidance describes the route as involving three-room or smaller flats, a qualifying family nucleus, prior structural feasibility assessment and formal resale approval. Once approved and combined, the home operates as a single converted flat under one lease rather than two freely separable apartments.

Owners should understand both timing and legal risk before paying an Option Fee. An existing owner generally has to fulfil the applicable Minimum Occupation Period before purchasing the adjoining unit; the resulting converted flat generally has a new five-year MOP before resale. HDB has also said it is reviewing the Conversion Scheme following concerns about a high-priced jumbo-flat listing in 2026. The scheme should therefore be checked against live HDB policies before any commitments, rather than treated as a permanent guarantee that a future neighbour’s unit can be bought.

  • Identify whether you are buying an existing jumbo flat or proposing a new conversion
  • verify both units are adjoining and meet HDB’s flat-type criteria
  • confirm a genuine qualifying family nucleus
  • obtain HFE and check the first flat’s MOP
  • submit the official feasibility enquiry before buying
  • check structural and fire-safety constraints
  • coordinate resale applications and financing
  • calculate CPF, stamp duty, legal and renovation costs
  • plan a new MOP after conversion
  • understand that a completed conversion is not freely reversible
  • and confirm the 2026 scheme review before relying on today’s rules.

Contents: From an adjoining-flat idea to a lawful jumbo home

1. A jumbo flat is a property history, not one standard layout

Jumbo flats are often described as very large HDB homes created by joining two smaller flats. Some were combined by HDB decades ago, while other households used a formal Conversion Scheme to purchase adjoining units and combine them.

There is no single jumbo floor plan, room count or fixed area. A converted unit may have unusual internal circulation, two former entrance locations or different plumbing routes compared with a purpose-built five-room or Executive flat.

Begin with the actual property records and approved plan rather than assuming every online listing using the word jumbo follows the same history or legal form.

2. The difference between buying a jumbo and creating one

Buying an existing legally converted jumbo flat is a resale transaction for one property. Creating a new jumbo flat requires obtaining HDB approval to acquire and combine two adjoining units under the Conversion Scheme.

The latter route has coordination risk: the adjoining unit must become available, the structural layout must be suitable, the applicant must qualify and both legal and renovation processes have to work.

Decide which route you are considering. Advice about buying a completed jumbo flat does not automatically establish permission to create a new one.

3. Why the Conversion Scheme was introduced

Introduced in 1993, the scheme was intended to provide eligible households facing space constraints with the opportunity to buy and connect an adjacent smaller flat. It lets some families remain in a familiar neighbourhood instead of moving elsewhere for more rooms.

That purpose does not convert the two units into an unrestricted private development. Public-housing eligibility, the statutory lease, occupation conditions and HDB approvals continue to apply.

Plan around actual family needs rather than solely around the idea that more floor area must mean better resale performance.

4. The current three-room-or-smaller criterion

Under the scheme described in HDB and contemporary reporting, eligible existing owners can seek to buy an adjoining three-room or smaller resale flat, generally alongside an existing qualifying smaller unit. A household without a current flat may be able to apply to buy two adjoining smaller flats together under the scheme.

The permitted configuration is not a general right to join any two large flats, or to connect floors through a common corridor without approval.

Obtain the specific address assessment from HDB and verify the policy remains in force. HDB’s 2026 review means old eligibility screenshots should not be treated as permanent rules.

5. A genuine family nucleus is important

The Conversion Scheme has been described as serving eligible married couples and qualifying families of parents and children, with relevant citizenship and household requirements. Singles and joint singles do not have a general entitlement to this family conversion route.

Do not invent household members or assume two unrelated friends can simply buy one small flat each and ask HDB to connect them. The resulting property is a subsidised public-housing home governed by household criteria.

Use HDB’s current HFE and scheme-specific guidance to establish who can legally own and occupy the converted unit.

6. A flat owner may need to complete the first MOP

An HDB owner considering a neighbour’s flat must satisfy current occupation and property-ownership requirements. Contemporary explanations of the Conversion Scheme note that an owner generally has to fulfil the original flat’s MOP before acquiring the adjoining unit.

This is different from simply adding an adult child’s name to an existing property. Buying a second adjoining flat requires a recognised conversion pathway rather than violating ordinary dual HDB ownership restrictions.

Check the precise MOP result and eligibility with HDB before negotiating a binding option with the neighbour.

7. The second purchase creates a new MOP

When HDB approves a conversion and the combined home is created, the converted property generally has a fresh five-year MOP before it can be sold in the resale market.

That clock can surprise owners who have already lived in the original apartment for many years and assume the first flat’s old MOP still controls every later transaction.

Map the resale horizon before committing. A converted home may be unsuitable for a family planning to relocate in two years.

8. Two legal flats are not always structurally joinable

Adjacent front doors do not establish that a dividing wall may be removed. Structural beams, reinforced concrete, service risers and fire-safety conditions can affect whether a lawful opening is possible.

HDB requires an assessment of the structural feasibility of combining the units. A contractor’s sketch or architect’s concept is not the same as official approval.

Make the technical enquiry an early go/no-go step, before paying large sums or making a long-term promise to the seller.

9. Use HDB’s formal Conversion Scheme enquiry

HDB provides an enquiry form asking for the relevant owner identity and addresses of the two proposed adjoining flats. The form makes clear that a feasibility enquiry is not acceptance of the later purchase application.

An owner receiving a preliminary positive response must still satisfy HDB’s prevailing resale eligibility and transaction conditions. The sequence matters because approval to join and eligibility to buy are separate questions.

Keep the HDB written outcome and update it if the parties or property circumstances change. Do not rely only on a verbal assurance from an agent.

10. The scheme is under review in 2026

After publicity about a high-priced converted flat in Telok Blangah, HDB announced a review of the Conversion Scheme. Current guidance therefore needs a clear date context and should be checked before each new application.

Review does not automatically mean the scheme has been abolished, nor does it guarantee that existing arrangements will remain unchanged. Outcomes and transitional treatment depend on formal HDB announcements.

Treat scheme rules stated in this article as a snapshot for research, not a promise of permanent eligibility at a future purchase date.

11. HFE and resale eligibility remain essential

An HDB Flat Eligibility letter assesses relevant household eligibility, grants and housing loan support. The conversion pathway is not a substitute for the underlying resale buyer assessment.

Check citizenship, family nucleus, age, existing residential interests and all core members. A family with unusual circumstances may need direct HDB guidance.

Obtain the appropriate HFE result before proceeding to an option or official resale application. A feasible wall opening cannot correct an ineligible purchase.

12. Buying two flats together creates coordination risk

A household purchasing two adjoining units from two sellers may have to coordinate two separate Options to Purchase, loan or CPF arrangements and resale application records. HDB’s e-Resale FAQ illustrates the ‘conversion’ designation in the buyer’s applications and the two property addresses.

Two sellers may have different moving dates, mortgage issues or willingness to accept an extension. One deal failing can undermine the reason for the other.

Use a solicitor or suitable professional advice and obtain HDB’s scheme instructions before promising the sellers that the transactions can be completed simultaneously.

13. How to submit the conversion indicator in applications

HDB’s resale FAQ says the buyer seeking to combine two adjoining flats must indicate ‘conversion’ and provide both flat addresses in the applicable resale application. The individual sellers do not simply file as though they were purchasers of the adjoining unit.

Follow the live portal prompts and HDB’s formal guidance. The purpose is to identify a special combined transaction rather than to submit two ordinary purchases that would appear to breach other-ownership rules.

Keep the two sale files separate but cross-referenced. A mistaken flat address or inconsistent applicant can create avoidable processing problems.

14. The original owner buying the neighbour’s flat

Where a family already owns one eligible smaller flat and plans to buy its immediate neighbour’s unit, the new acquisition is not just an interior renovation. It must satisfy HDB’s resale and conversion requirements.

Confirm the existing property is eligible and its MOP fulfilled, then enquire whether the adjacent flat can be combined. Discuss the intended resale contract only after the core feasibility and financing questions are addressed.

Do not assume a next-door seller’s informal agreement is HDB approval. The seller can agree to a sale that the buyer later cannot legally complete.

15. How the combined property becomes one legal flat

When approved conversion is completed, the two units are treated as one combined HDB property under one lease. The legal consequence matters for future sale and the ability to change ownership.

An owner should not plan to operate it as two independent flats after conversion merely because two former kitchens or entrances remain visible. The official legal and technical status governs permissible use.

Ask HDB and the conveyancing party for the final registered property details and keep the approved floor plan.

16. Combining does not mean you can freely split it later

Current reporting of HDB’s conversion rules states that approved converted jumbo flats are to remain single combined flats and cannot be casually split back into two units for separate resale.

This creates long-term flexibility risk. A household that expects two children to inherit or sell the halves separately should not rely on that imagined future outcome.

Plan the decision as acquiring one unusual home with a single legal market, not two liquid assets that can be divided whenever desired.

17. Resale after conversion can be a niche market

Jumbo flats can have striking floor area but a smaller pool of buyers who need that amount of space and can finance the purchase. Their unusual layouts, remaining leases and market prices can complicate future resale.

An advertised record-high jumbo price is not proof every comparable property will achieve it. Compare registered transactions, property condition, lease, layout and nearby alternatives.

Recognise that selling may take time. A household should be comfortable keeping the combined property if the next buyer does not appear immediately.

18. Remaining lease still matters

Combining two older flats does not automatically give the resulting unit a fresh 99-year HDB lease. The existing legal term or resulting term must be established through HDB’s approved transaction documentation.

CPF housing withdrawal and borrowing can be affected by remaining lease, age and property valuation. A very large apartment may require unusually significant cash if its financing is constrained.

Ask for property-specific CPF and loan calculations instead of treating floor area as the sole driver of financial value.

19. A larger home can have a larger maintenance budget

More rooms and bathrooms can mean more plumbing, air-conditioning, appliances, painting and interior surfaces to maintain. Some original services may remain complex after conversion.

Estimate running costs before buying. A jumbo flat can be comfortable for a multi-generation family, but it may be expensive to clean and maintain when the household becomes smaller.

Do not assume the per-square-metre purchase price tells the full ownership cost. Look at both initial and recurring cash requirements.

20. Plan the lawful connecting opening

Structural design is the most consequential part of the physical conversion. HDB and relevant Qualified Persons must assess whether and where a partition or wall opening may be formed.

Do not allow an interior contractor to cut into reinforced concrete because the two former living rooms appear aligned. Building structure and essential services may be hidden.

The renovation contract should make approvals a condition and specify professional responsibilities, schedule, safe work methods and reinstatement.

21. Fire safety must remain functional

Combining two flat layouts can affect escape routes, entrance arrangements, fire separation and access to emergency systems. Official technical approval should determine the permitted construction details.

An unapproved connection through a corridor or a blocked shared exit can create safety consequences for neighbours, not just the household.

Use appropriately registered contractors and follow HDB renovation rules. The goal is a functional single home that remains safe for every occupant.

22. Check old kitchens, bathrooms and services

Two formerly independent flats may retain separate plumbing and electrical layouts. The owner may want to convert a second kitchen into another room or make a large family space.

Such redesign can involve regulated plumbing, wet areas and structural considerations. Assess service routes and existing condition before paying for custom carpentry.

Not every desired conversion is approved merely because the underlying two-flat joining is possible. Identify each renovation stage separately.

23. Use a realistic financing and stamp-duty model

Buying one or two resale flats involves legal fees, stamp duty, CPF eligibility, loan valuation and cash requirements. The exact application and financing sequence can differ under the Conversion Scheme.

Obtain separate values and a coordinated financial plan before exercising options. Two large transactions cannot be funded simply by adding together optimistic bank estimates.

Ask the lender and HDB how the combined legal property and security will be handled. Preserve emergency reserves for renovation surprises.

24. Do not use the asking price to establish value

Marketed jumbo flats can have impressive headline prices because they are rare. Price should still be analysed using actual transacted data, unit area, location and remaining lease.

Where same-type comparables are scarce, expand cautiously to alternative large flats or two smaller units, clearly noting legal and layout differences.

Do not invent an exact valuation from a single unusual sale. Ask appropriate professionals for a property-specific assessment where the financial consequence is large.

25. A family that grows may value flexibility

A multi-generation household may benefit from more bedrooms, study space or a separate living area. Those advantages are real even if they do not produce guaranteed investment returns.

Think about accessibility, kitchen use, noise and privacy. A long internal route or poorly positioned bathroom can make a very large flat less convenient for an older parent.

Plan from actual daily tasks, not just a claim that ‘more rooms is always better’.

26. A family that shrinks may face a different need

Children may move out, older parents may need care elsewhere and a household’s cleaning and mortgage priorities can change. A jumbo flat can become more space than its remaining occupants want to maintain.

Before buying, ask whether there is a plausible ten-year plan to remain, or whether resale could be needed soon. The new MOP and narrower buyer market matter.

A home should be a sustainable choice even if a planned future sale proves slower or less profitable than expected.

27. If a seller advertises an already-converted jumbo

Ask for HDB’s legal description, approved floor plan, resale eligibility conditions, remaining lease and evidence that the conversion was properly completed. A connected interior does not automatically prove a valid permanent merger.

Inspect each former unit’s condition and the connection between them. Check whether plumbing, ventilation, waterproofing and doors have been maintained adequately.

Build the purchase budget from one actual legal property and relevant HDB resale requirements, not from an assumption that the buyer is acquiring two separately tradeable flats.

28. The risk of a failed second-flat deal

A household that already owns one flat might obtain a promising technical assessment but fail to agree a price with the neighbour. The scheme cannot force a neighbour to sell.

Conversely, a seller may be ready while the buyer cannot obtain enough financing or HDB eligibility. This is why conditional planning and professional advice are useful before spending substantial money.

Treat the adjoining purchase as contingent on independent decisions, not as a guaranteed upgrade route.

29. What the 2026 review means for future buyers

HDB’s announced review could affect who may combine flats or how proposals are evaluated. Until a formal change is issued, buyers should consult the current scheme and ask HDB about prospective applications.

A family considering an uncertain 2027 purchase should not prepay renovation designs for a conversion that depends on a neighbour selling and regulations remaining the same.

Use a dated source register and obtain direct confirmation before an option. Policy uncertainty is an important part of the project’s risk.

30. The end-to-end conversion checklist

First identify the two potential units and family nucleus. Second verify original MOP and HFE eligibility. Third obtain HDB’s structural feasibility response and clarify the 2026 review status.

Fourth negotiate and document both transactions lawfully, with enough time for proper resale and loan processing. Fifth obtain permits, complete approved structural joining and retain the resulting legal records.

Finally, budget and observe the fresh MOP and maintain the combined flat as a single home. The point is to gain usable family space without creating avoidable legal, financial or resale problems.

50 Jumbo Flat and Conversion Scheme situations

These illustrations are not a personal eligibility determination or a guarantee that HDB will allow the transaction. The scheme is under review; verify present rules with HDB.

1. A 3-room owner wants to buy the next-door 3-room unit

This may be a Conversion Scheme candidate, but MOP, family nucleus and HDB structural approval must be confirmed first. The neighbour is not obliged to sell.

2. A 4-room owner wants to join another 4-room flat

Do not assume the scheme applies: current descriptions generally concern three-room or smaller flats. Ask HDB rather than advertising a guaranteed merge.

3. Two citizens under the Joint Singles Scheme want two adjoining flats

The Conversion Scheme has specific family-nucleus criteria and is not a general joint-singles entitlement. Verify before entering two purchase options.

4. A married couple with children wants more bedrooms

Consider whether combining qualifying adjoining smaller flats meets the real need and is structurally possible. A large home still needs manageable expenses and an appropriate layout.

5. A family plans to create two rental flats behind one door

Approved conversion produces a single property rather than freely separate units. HDB rental and MOP conditions continue to apply.

6. The owner has only completed three years of MOP

Check the required original occupation period. An incomplete MOP can prevent an adjoining purchase under current rules.

7. The owner has lived in the first flat for twenty years

A new MOP generally begins when the combined home is created. Do not count the original twenty years as an exemption from the converted property’s resale condition.

8. The neighbour wants an immediate option fee

Ask HDB about feasibility and eligibility before committing. A contract that the buyer cannot complete can create financial loss.

9. The two doors are adjacent but a load-bearing wall divides them

A visual adjacency is insufficient. HDB must assess whether a lawful structural connection can be approved.

10. A renovation contractor promises to hack through overnight

Do not permit unauthorised structural works. Obtain HDB and applicable professional approval before any wall alteration.

11. The two flats are on separate floors

The scheme’s adjoining-flat criteria are not a general licence to connect properties by a private staircase. Seek HDB’s determination.

12. The sellers have different completion timelines

Coordinate the transactions through the correct resale process. If the timing fails, the combined-purchase plan may become impractical.

13. One seller withdraws before agreement

The buyer cannot force a sale merely because the other property is available. Reassess the plan rather than assuming HDB can supply a replacement unit.

14. The household wants to buy two flats together

HDB’s resale FAQ shows the buyer indicating ‘conversion’ and both addresses in its applications. Obtain current portal instructions and full eligibility assessment.

15. A buyer’s HFE letter is near expiry

Check the relevant validity and update requirements before submitting both transaction applications. Incorrect buyer details can stop progress.

16. One unit has a leaking bathroom

Inspect both former flats; conversion does not eliminate physical defects. Budget repairs and consider technical effects on the planned merged layout.

17. The family wants to remove a former kitchen

Check plumbing, water and service routes and applicable permits. A former kitchen cannot always be converted solely by removing cabinets.

18. The merged flat will have two entrances

Ask HDB and technical advisers which entrances and fire features may remain. The approved combined plan governs the result.

19. A child wants to inherit half of the jumbo independently

A completed conversion is treated as one property and cannot simply be divided into two resale units. Seek proper estate and title advice.

20. The neighbour says both flats can be sold separately later

Do not assume a lawful completed conversion is reversible. Check HDB’s actual legal property status and restrictions.

21. A news report shows a S$2 million jumbo asking price

An asking price is not a registered completed transaction or a guarantee. Compare actual comparable sales, lease and condition.

22. The owner wants a larger personal home rather than an investment

Evaluate rooms, privacy, family routines and cost. A genuine household need may justify a niche large flat without requiring guaranteed resale profits.

23. A prospective buyer has very little cash

Two purchases and joining works can generate complex financing and renovation costs. Do not rely on maximum speculative loan and CPF amounts.

24. One unit has a much shorter remaining lease

Ask HDB about compatibility and resulting legal tenure. Do not invent a fresh uniform lease simply because the two interiors can connect.

25. A family has elderly parents with mobility difficulties

Check bathroom access, internal distances and lifts. More rooms do not automatically create a more accessible home.

26. A jumbo flat has outdated wiring

Obtain qualified assessment; two older electrical systems may require careful renovation. A large area magnifies repair costs.

27. A seller markets an already-converted jumbo without records

Ask for HDB’s approved legal property details and plans. A hacked opening alone does not prove a lawful conversion.

28. The buyer plans to resell in two years

A fresh five-year MOP for a converted flat can conflict with that plan. Check actual HDB terms before purchasing.

29. A household is worried about long-run liquidity

A rare jumbo may have fewer buyers than an ordinary 4- or 5-room flat. Choose it only if comfortable with possible longer resale periods.

30. An agent claims HDB no longer permits any conversion

HDB announced a review in 2026; a review is not itself a blanket abolition. Check live formal guidance and scheme availability.

31. Another agent claims conversion rules can never change

The announced review makes that assurance unsupported. Verify current policy when applying rather than relying on an old article.

32. The property is in a mature estate

Location can be useful, but determine actual leases, price, transport and upkeep. Mature status does not override HDB conversion conditions.

33. A family wants a home office and study rooms

Plan a layout that fits work and household use, but do not assume every internal wall can be moved. Obtain approved plans.

34. A lender offers a preliminary valuation on one unit

Two units and resulting legal property may be treated differently. Ask for a coordinated financing plan for the actual transaction.

35. The owner plans to borrow for structural renovations

Check borrowing limits, cash and contractors separately. An HDB resale loan does not automatically finance every renovation cost.

36. A buyer intends to use CPF balances from several people

CPF use depends on legal ownership and individual limits. Confirm permissible members and amounts before counting funding.

37. The family wants to purchase next door in ten years

There is no guarantee the neighbour will sell or the policy will remain the same. Consider present alternatives and avoid betting all future housing plans on the scheme.

38. A couple has not yet formed a qualifying family nucleus

The conversion route is not automatically open to every pair of purchasers. Check HDB citizenship, relationship and household criteria.

39. The combined flat has two living rooms

This may offer flexibility, but assess storage, noise, circulation and long-term maintenance. Extra rooms can become awkward rather than useful.

40. A buyer wants to compare jumbo with an Executive flat

Compare legal flat type, remaining lease, floor area, design, resale restrictions, price and financing. Similar size does not mean identical property rights.

41. A family changes plans during renovation

Obtain updated HDB permission before modifying the approved connection or regulated features. A changed design may alter structural or service compliance.

42. A former bedroom becomes a bathroom

Wet-area relocation is subject to technical restrictions. Do not assume changing room use is an unrestricted cosmetic choice.

43. A converted flat receives an unusually high offer

Check MOP completion and HDB resale rules before accepting a binding option. An attractive price does not waive occupation requirements.

44. A sibling hopes to buy out the other

Treat co-ownership changes and transfer as legal and financial transactions. Check HDB eligibility, loan, CPF and stamp duty requirements.

45. An estate agent says jumbo flats always rise in price

Market prices are uncertain and niche units may be illiquid. Use official transaction evidence and the household’s real needs.

46. Two sellers want different deposits

Read both proper OTPs and their deadlines, and coordinate with legal and HDB processes. Avoid informal side payments.

47. The household cannot obtain technical approval

Do not connect the units privately. Reassess buying one flat or moving to a permitted larger property.

48. A family has completed the new MOP

The converted flat may be eligible for resale subject to other conditions. Verify the official property record, title, HFE requirements for the buyer and actual sale process.

49. The home is advertised as two 3-room flats sold as one

Confirm whether it is an approved converted property rather than two independently held flats. The legal distinction affects ownership and financing.

50. The owner is ready to apply

Document family nucleus, MOP, property addresses, HDB structural feasibility, financing and renovation plans. Do not let a seller’s enthusiasm replace formal clearance.

Frequently asked questions

What is an HDB jumbo flat?

A very large public-housing unit, often made by combining two smaller adjoining flats, with a legal status that must be verified.

Can an owner still join two HDB flats?

HDB has a Conversion Scheme for eligible families and qualifying adjoining smaller flats, but announced a review in 2026. Confirm current eligibility.

Does the scheme apply to any two flat sizes?

No. Current guidance generally concerns adjoining 3-room or smaller flats and a qualifying family nucleus.

Can single people use the Conversion Scheme freely?

No. The family-nucleus requirements differ from ordinary singles and Joint Singles purchasing routes.

Is HDB structural approval required?

Yes. Enquiry about feasibility should occur before committing to the combined purchase.

Does the existing MOP have to be met?

An existing owner generally needs to fulfil applicable occupation conditions before acquiring the adjoining unit.

Is there a new MOP after combining?

Current explanations indicate a fresh five-year MOP for the converted property.

Can an approved jumbo later be split and sold as two?

Not as an automatic right. Current rules treat it as one combined property and do not generally permit a casual reversal.

Does joining flats restart their lease to 99 years?

No automatic fresh 99-year lease is created by the act of combining interiors. Verify the resulting legal tenure with HDB.

Can two flats be bought from two sellers at once?

The scheme can involve two linked resale applications; obtain HDB’s specific instructions and coordinated legal and financial advice.

Has the scheme been abolished?

HDB announced a 2026 review following high-priced jumbo listings; review is not itself confirmation of abolition. Check live rules.

Is a S$2 million jumbo asking price a market valuation?

No. Asking prices are not necessarily completed transactions; compare actual sales and property condition.

What is the first step?

Seek HDB’s structural feasibility and eligibility assessment for the two exact addresses before binding purchase commitments.

Official documents and 2026 scheme context

The Conversion Scheme was subject to a reported HDB review in 2026. HDB’s current formal eligibility, feasibility and transaction requirements supersede general explanations here; obtain dated case-specific confirmation.

Editorial review 7 November 2026. General housing education; not an official HDB approval, survey or legal advice. The immutable Clementi reference was preserved.